Mon–Thu 8AM–5PM | Fri 8AM–2PM

Open Select Saturdays

Home  /  General Dentistry  /  Tooth Extractions

Tooth Extractions in Cary, NC

When a tooth cannot be saved, New Day Dental & Medical Aesthetics removes it gently, with clear aftercare and a plan for what comes next, from healing to replacing the tooth.

Happy patient looking into the camera with a beautiful smile.

Save first

Extraction only when repair is not the better option

3D imaging

CBCT scans to map roots and nearby structures

In-network

with Delta Dental and Blue Cross Blue Shield

Saturdays

Open select Saturdays for busy schedules

Tooth removal

When Removing a Tooth Is the Healthier Choice

Most of the time, the goal is to keep your natural teeth. A filling, crown, or root canal can often save a tooth that looks badly damaged. Sometimes, though, a tooth has too much decay, too little support from the bone and gums, or a crack that runs too deep to repair. Holding on to it can mean ongoing pain, repeated infections, and risk to the teeth around it.

At New Day Dental & Medical Aesthetics, we take a conservative approach. Dr. Jordan Tucker looks at every option first and recommends an extraction only when it is the right choice for your long-term oral health. Extractions are part of our general dentistry care, and we plan the next step with you, whether that is simply letting the area heal or replacing the tooth.

How it works

What to Expect During a Tooth Extraction

Most extractions are finished in a single visit. Here is how the process works at our Cary office.

Exam and Imaging

We examine the tooth and take X-rays, using 3D imaging when we need a closer look at the roots and surrounding bone.

Numbing

The area is numbed before anything begins, so you feel pressure rather than pain during the extraction.

Removing the Tooth

A tooth that is fully visible is gently loosened and lifted out. A broken or hard-to-reach tooth may need a small opening in the gum or removal in sections.

Aftercare

We place gauze, review written aftercare instructions, and stay available by phone if questions come up while you heal.

Protect the healing site

After an extraction, a blood clot forms in the socket as the area begins to heal. The American Dental Association advises avoiding smoking, vigorous rinsing, and drinking through a straw for the first 24 hours, and gently brushing the other teeth as usual. Call us if swelling or pain increases.

Why New Day Dental

Extractions With a Plan for What Comes Next

Removing a tooth is rarely the end of the story. Here is how we help you through the whole process.

Detailed 3D Imaging

Dr. Tucker is trained in CBCT cone beam imaging, which shows the roots and nearby structures before a more involved extraction is planned.

A Conservative First Look

We explore fillings, crowns, and root canals before recommending removal, and explain why when extraction is the better choice.

Replacement Planning Up Front

We talk through implants, bridges, and dentures before the extraction, so you know what comes next and can plan around it.

Is it necessary?

When an Extraction May Be Recommended

Every case is different. These are common situations where removal makes sense, and others where we try to save the tooth first.

Extraction Is Often Recommended for

We May Try to Save the Tooth if

If extraction is the right option, Dr. Tucker will explain why and walk you through replacement choices. Wisdom teeth have their own considerations, covered on our wisdom teeth removal page.

Insurance & payment

Paying for a Tooth Extraction

The cost of an extraction depends on the tooth, how it is positioned, and whether a bone graft or replacement is part of your plan. Our team explains your out-of-pocket cost before treatment.

Dental Insurance

Many dental plans cover part of an extraction. We accept most major PPO plans, are in-network with Delta Dental and Blue Cross Blue Shield, and verify your benefits before treatment.

VIP Membership Plan

No insurance? Our in-house plan covers preventive care and adds discounts on additional treatment for one flat annual fee. See the VIP Membership Plan

Flexible Financing

Financing options are available for larger treatment plans, such as an extraction followed by an implant or bridge. Ask our team about options.

Before you book

How to Prepare for Your Extraction

These simple steps can make the day of your extraction and the first few days afterward go more smoothly.

Dr. J. Tucker, DDS at New Day Dental & Medical Aesthetics, portrait in white dental coat

CBCT

3D imaging trained

Your dentist

Meet Dr. Jordan Tucker, DDS

Owner & lead dentist

Dr. Tucker completed undergraduate studies as a scholarship student-athlete and went on to earn a dental degree from West Virginia University. Before leading New Day Dental & Medical Aesthetics, Dr. Tucker owned a private practice and served as clinical faculty, mentoring future dental professionals.

When a tooth is in trouble, Dr. Tucker looks for ways to save it first and explains the tradeoffs clearly when it cannot be saved. Training in CBCT cone beam imaging and CEREC same-day restorations means you can see what is happening with the tooth and plan your replacement in the same office. Read Dr. Tucker’s full bio

Patient reviews

What Our Patients Say

FAQ

Tooth Extraction Questions, Answered

Do not see your question here? Call us and our team will help.

Does a Tooth Extraction Hurt?

The area is numbed before the extraction begins, so most people feel pressure rather than pain. Some soreness afterward is normal and usually improves over a few days with the care instructions we give you.

Many people return to normal activities within a few days. The gum and bone continue healing over the following weeks. Following your aftercare instructions helps the site heal well.

Stick with soft foods like yogurt, soup that is not too hot, eggs, and mashed potatoes for the first few days. Chew on the other side of your mouth and avoid crunchy or sticky foods near the site.

In most cases, replacing a missing tooth helps keep your bite stable and stops nearby teeth from drifting. Dental implants, bridges, and dentures are all options we can discuss.

Often, yes. A filling, crown, or root canal can save many damaged teeth. We recommend an extraction only when repairing the tooth is not the better long-term option.

Call our office at (919) 701-2922. Sudden pain, swelling, or a broken tooth may need urgent care, and our emergency dentistry team can help you decide on next steps.

Get started

Schedule Your Extraction Consult in Cary Today

Dr. Jordan Tucker and our team evaluate damaged teeth, provide gentle extractions when they are needed, and plan replacements in our Cary office, with in-network coverage for Delta Dental and Blue Cross Blue Shield.

Call (919) 701-2922 or complete our contact form to schedule your visit. We welcome patients from Cary, Apex, Holly Springs, Morrisville, and across Wake County.

Visit us

1223 Parkside Main St.
Cary, NC 27519
Get directions →

Office hours

Monday
8AM – 4PM
Tuesday
8AM – 5PM
Wednesday
8AM – 4PM
Thursday
8AM – 5PM
Friday
8AM – 2PM
Saturday
Select dates